Best Pillows – Full Review Guide

So, what makes the best pillow? This is a common question that doesn’t have a straight forward answer because there are so many different types of pillows with different filings, firmness and lofts.

The pillow that will be best for you will be determined by your individual sleeping style, but we’ve created this guide to answer your questions and show you the benefits and drawbacks of each type of pillow allowing you to make an easy buying decision.

Our Top Rated Pillows

Image

Name

Material

Firmness

Position

panda-pillow-review

Panda Luxury Memory Foam Bamboo Pillow

Memory Foam & Bamboo

Medium 

Any

Simba-memory-foam-pillow-review

Simba Luxury Memory Foam Pillow

Memory Foam

Medium 

Any

hungarian-feather-down

John Lewis Hungarian Goose Down and Feather Pillow

Goose and Duck Down

Medium/Firm

Back & Side Sleepers

tempur-pillow-firm

Tempur Firm Pillow

Memory Foam

Firm

Back

soak-sleep-down-feather

Soak & Sleep Ultimate 90% Hungarian Goose Down Pillow

Goose Down

Soft/Medium & Medium/Firm

Any

Memory-foam-pillow-john-lewis

John Lewis Specialist Synthetic 2-Way Memory Foam Support Pillow

Memory Foam

Medium/Firm 

Back & Side Sleepers

dunlopillo-latex-pillow

Dunlopillo Latex Pillow

Latex

Medium/Firm

Back & Side Sleepers

Soft-goose-down-john-lewis

John Lewis Natural White Goose Down Pillow 

Goose Down

Soft/Medium

 Front and back Sleepers

calming-breath-buckwheat-pillow

CalmingBreath Buckwheat Pillow

Latex

Firm

Back & Side Sleepers

sealy-latex-pillow

Sealy Posturepedic Optimal Latex Pillow

Latex

Firm

Back & Side Sleepers

​Panda Luxury Memory Foam Bamboo Pillow

panda-pillow-review

The Original Panda pillow is manufactured using bamboo memory foam and has a triple layer of moulded memory foam to increase the level of comfort and support. The pillow has great temperature regulating technology which works to keep you warm in the winter and cool throughout summer as it allows air to freely flow through the material.

Bamboo is naturally mould resistant and anti bacterial which protects your skin against irritation. The bamboo fabric is also classified as anti static so it so doesn’t cling to your skin whilst you sleep.

The pillow is suited to side, back and front sleepers and keeps your neck and spine supported aligned throughout.

The pillow is recommended by doctors and orthopaedic experts alike and includes a 10 year manufacturer guarantee in addition to a 100% money back guarantee if you’re not fully happy with the results you experience by using this pillow.

Benefits

  • Bamboo Memory foam
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Temperature Regulating
  • 10 year Guarantee

Simba Luxury Memory Foam Pillow

Simba-memory-foam-pillow-review

Simba have a simple mission statement to make sleeping simple by using the latest advancements in technology and data to make market leading products that adapt to each user’s individual sleep needs.

They have created this state of the art pillow made from soft memory foam that works to adapt and contour to the shape of your neck and head offering unbeatable support.

The pillow is fantastic for all sleeping positons including side, front and back sleepers and works to keep your spine aligned while you sleep. The high quality memory foam returns to its orginal shape once you have finished using it.

Also included is a 100% hypoallergenic removable machine washable cover so even the users who are extremely sensitive to allergies can use this without issues.

Benefits

  • Soft Memory Foam Contours and Hugs to Your Body
  • Suitable for Front, Back and Side Sleepers
  • Hypoallergenic Pillow
  • Temperature Regulating
  • 10 year Warranty

John Lewis Hungarian Goose Down and Feather Pillow

hungarian-feather-down

This UK made pillow has a feather core to provide support to your neck and head, with a cosy and soft down filing which is extremely comfortable to sleep on for long periods of time, so you wake up feeling relaxed.

The pillow is covered in a removable pure cotton down-proof cover which prevents filings from escaping from the pillow. The pillow is medium-firm and works to keep your spine aligned and neck supported.

The fabric of the cover is tightly weaved to create a barrier against dust mites reducing the effects of allergies.

It also comes with a two year warranty, and with John Lewis you can be assured that you’re buying a high quality product.

Benefits

  • Down and Feather Blend
  • Provides Both Comfort & Support
  • UK Made
  • Removable Cover
  • 5 year Warranty

​TEMPUR® Traditional Pillow Firm

tempur-pillow-firm

Tempur were one of the first manufacturers to use memory foam as a retail product and have been in the market for many years. This firm pillow is suited to those who crave that extra firmness that isn’t gained from a medium-firm memory foam pillow.

Tempur use premium materials so this product will last for many years before it eventually loses shape as with all pillows.

The key benefit of memory foam is that it allows your neck and head to sink into the foam whilst keeping you supported, then when the pressure is released it returns to its original shape. The pillow comes with a 100% soft cotton cover. In addition there is a 3 year warranty provided for added peace of mind.

Benefits

  • Firm Memory Foam Material
  • High Quality Support
  • Removable Washable Cover
  • 3 year Warranty

Soak & Sleep Ultimate 90% Hungarian Goose Down Pillow

soak-sleep-down-feather

This Soak & sleep pillow provides you with a choice of firmness to suit your sleeping style and position. It's manufactured using 90% Hungarian Goose Down for a comfortable outer layer with a Goose Feather core to provide support to your neck and head.

The soft/medium pillow has a lower profile which makes it ideal for front and side sleepers whereas the medium/firm option provides more support making it ideal for back and side sleepers.

The Hungarian Down is washed in natural spring water and is free of harsh chemicals leading to it being approved by Oeko-Tex, EDFA and No-mite, whilst being encased in a soft 280 thread count casing for added soft plush comfort.

You know that you’re getting a premium product made from premium materials.

Benefits

  • Goose Down and Feather blend
  • Supportive Yet comfortable
  • Choice of Firmness
  • Free of Harsh Chemicals

​John Lewis Specialist Synthetic 2-Way Memory Foam Support Pillow

Memory-foam-pillow-john-lewis

John Lewis has manufactured a specialist memory foam pillow that is suitable for both back and side sleepers. The shape of the pillow is shaped differently at both ends, with the larger contoured end supporting spine alignment for side sleepers. The opposite end has a shallower end which is suited to back sleepers.

This pillow is great if you like using memory foam but find the Tempur pillow to be too firm. This provides an ideal combination of sink and support so you don’t feel like you’re overheating throughout the night.

Also included is a five year warranty so if any defects develop with the product then you can return to the John Lewis for a free replacement.

Benefits

  • 2 Way Memory Foam
  • Improves Pressure and Aches
  • Back Support and Spine Alignment
  • Five Year Warranty

​Dunlopillo Super Comfort Full Latex Firm Pillow

dunlopillo-latex-pillow

Dunlopillo have created this signature latex pillow made from Talalay latex, which when used relieves pressure and tension from your neck and head area with a medium/firm rating.

Latex is traditionally dense, however this doesn’t cause you to overheat because air can flow in and out of the pillow with ease so you stay cool through the summer months.

The latex used is 100% natural so you can be assured that this is the best quality latex pillow available on the market.

The pillow is also mite free and hypoallergenic so it's even suitable to those who suffer from allergies. The pillow aids blood flow so your cells can repair at a faster rate throughout your sleep, whilst the pillow comes in a removable machine washable cover.

Benefits

  • 100% Natural Latex
  • Relieves Tension
  • Added Comfort
  • Temperature Regulating
  • Machine Washable Cover

John Lewis Natural White Goose Down Pillow 

Soft-goose-down-john-lewis

Front sleepers require a pillow that's slightly thinner and is softer in firmness and this John Lewis Natural White Goose Down Standard Pillow fits these needs. The soft firmness allows you to sink into the pillow whilst retaining the supportive feeling.

This pillow is made so the Down is breathable which allows air to flow in and out of the pillow to wick away moisture throughout the night, improving the quality of your sleep. The pillow has a removable soft cover which is machine washable whilst also being Nomite rated making it suitable for users with dust mite allergies.

The pillow comes with a 5 year manufacturers warranty which protects you against any potential defects that may occur with the product.

Benefits

  • Ideal for front and back sleepers
  • Soft/medium firmness
  • Nomite rated
  • 5 Year Warranty

CalmingBreath Buckwheat Pillow

calming-breath-buckwheat-pillow

Buckwheat is a newer type of pillow filling that is fast gaining popularity within the pillow market. The buckwheat is triple cleaned and contains hulls that work individually to contour and mould to the shape of your neck, head and shoulders while you sleep keeping you comfortable.

Buckwheat filling also works to relieve existing pain that you may be suffering from with many users having reported this especially for neck pain. The pillow is also temperature regulating providing warmth throughout the winter and cooling in the summer month as air can circulate through the pillow with ease.

Because the Buckwheat can move around freely inside the pillow, you can mould it into any position you like which makes it suitable for a range of sleeping positions whether you’re a front, back or side sleeper.

Benefits

  • Triple Cleaned
  • Contours to body shape
  • Pain Relieving
  • Temperature Regulation

​Sealy Posturepedic Optimal Latex Pillow

sealy-latex-pillow

Sealy have manufactured this pillow using natural latex which not only provides support but also bounce back when you change position whilst you sleep. This has been designed for back and side sleepers.

The latex is also vented so air can flow in and out of the material to keep you cool as you sleep. This pillow has gone through many revisions to ensure that it has the optimal firmness, design and height.

The latex is firm which makes sure your spine remains aligned and supported whilst also being cosy to sleep on so it doesn’t feel like you’re sleeping on a solid rock. Buying a higher quality pillow like this ends up being more affordable than having to constantly buy and replace cheaper pillows.

The pillow is supplied with a removable cover which can be machine washed so you can keep the surface that your face touches fresh and clean.

Benefits

  • Natural, vented latex
  • Supportive and cosy
  • Natural Bounce Back Responsiveness
  • Removable cover
  • 3 year Warranty

Best Pillow By Material & Type

The material of the pillow is an important factor because it determines the feeling, comfort, durability and cooling ability of the pillow. There's never going to be a single pillow type that is the best because different sleeping styles are better suited to different types of pillow materials. We’ll take you through the different types including the positives and negatives.

Different Forms of Foam

Even though there are three main types of memory foam, there are three forms that the foam can come in, with each bringing different benefits.

Moulded

This usually comes in the solid block of foam which allows you to sink into it as it contours around your body making it outstanding for comfort. The most popular foam pillows come in this form and are also ideal for providing relief to those that already with existing pain.

Shredded

Shredded foam pillows are made using thousands of small sized foam shreds which are then packed closely together inside the pillow. This allows the pillow to be more breathable and also adjustable in height and shape.

Noodle

Noodle foam is manufactured into long noodle shapes which can vary in length and width. It's similar to shredded foam with strong breathability to keep you cool, and also the filling binds together more easily so it retains its original shape more than shredded foam.

Memory Foam

Memory foam is one of the most popular pillow fillings especially amongst those who struggle with pain along their neck, shoulders and back. Memory foam contours to the shape of your head and shoulders providing support whilst also having a degree of sink so it’s also extremely comfortable.

Memory foam relieves pressure and tension from your joints and muscles as you can fully relax them throughout your sleep.

The added benefit of memory foam is that once you’ve finished using it, it returns to its original shape. Traditionally memory foam used to sleep very hot, however newer memory foam models incorporate new cooling layers that allow air to flow easily through the materials.

Memory foams comes in a range of forms including the traditional block to shredded and noodle.

Pros

  • Contours to your body
  • Relieves pressure
  • Support
  • Long Lasting

Cons

  • Can have strong initial odour

Our top performers:

  • Simba Luxury Memory Foam Pillow
  • Panda Luxury Memory Foam Bamboo Pillow

Find out more about memory foam pillows in our buyers guide

Latex

Latex pillow filling is extracted from rubber trees in the form of sap, which is then further treated to create the final version. There are two types of Latex pillow, natural and synthetic.

Latex pillows keep overheating to a minimum as they allow air to flow in and out of the pillow, so this is a cooler version of memory foam. Latex retains its shape over a long period of time and contours to the shape of your body each time that you use it providing added support to your shoulders, head and neck.

Latex pillows also work to maintain natural alignment and are hypoallergenic so is great if you suffer from allergies.

Pros

  • Natural
  • Airflow
  • Long Lasting
  • Support

Cons

  • More Costly

Our top performers

  • Dunlopillo Super Comfort Full Latex Firm Pillow Review
  • Sealy Posturepedic Optimal Latex Pillow – Firm Review

Find out more about Latex pillows in our buyers guide

Polyurethane Foam

Polyurethane Foam is the most affordable option of the three and provides a more balanced feel which has less support and comfort. It does mean that it’s more cooler than memory foam.

Because it has the least natural manufacturing process it does have a stronger initial odour when you purchase it. We would recommend that you spend a little bit more to get a traditional memory foam or latex version if you want to experience all of the benefits.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Balanced feeling
  • Airflow

Cons

  • Less contouring
  • Stronger odour
  • Less contouring

Natural & Organic

The first thing to understand is that natural and organic are two separate things.

A natural pillow means that it has been manufactured using materials that are natural which could be cotton, wool, natural latex etc. It essentially just means that the materials are found in the natural environment but doesn’t include how these materials are treated during manufacturing.

An organic pillow uses natural materials but uses processes that are also organic which means that it's free of harmful chemicals and pesticides.  This also means that the product has to go through third party auditing by an official board for the product to be certified as organic.

The main natural & organic pillow fillings include Down Feather, Buckwheat, Cotton & Polyester.

Down Feather

Down feathers are usually sourced from Geese, ducks and occasionally swans, and are soft in feel creating a soft plush pillow. Feathers of different densities are often blended together to create different levels of firmness.

These types of pillows generally have a greater loft which keeps your head and neck in a higher position. Heat is not retained in Down & feather pillows and they can alter the shape so it suits your sleeping position.

Over time the cheaper Down Feather pillows begin to flatten out, however they're often more affordable than other types of pillows. It’s important to note that the majority of Down pillows need to be dry cleaned and can’t be machine washed.

Pros

  • Good loft
  • Cooling
  • Plush Feel

Cons

  • More Expensive to Clean

Our Top Performers:

  • Soak & Sleep Ultimate 90% Hungarian Goose Down Pillow
  • John Lewis 90/10 Goose and Duck Down Standard Pillow, Medium/Firm Review

Find out more about Down Feather pillows in our buyers guide

Buckwheat

If you’re looking for a natural or organic pillow then a buckwheat pillow could be very suitable for you. Buckwheat hulls are used to fill the pillow which makes them very dense and firm so you’ll feel well supported as you sleep.

Because each hull works individually from the other, Buckwheat pillows are adjustable so you can mould them into your desired shape which makes them suitable for all sleeping positions. This also makes them very breathable as there is space between the hulls for air to circulate.

If you suffer from allergies then this pillow is suitable for you as it's hypoallergenic. You can tell the difference between this and unnatural pillows because this has a strong fresh smell which will also aid you to get to sleep easier and the smell will relax you.

Pros

  • Mouldable
  • Cooling
  • Natural
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Can be noisy
  • Difficult to clean

Our top performers

CalmingBreath Buckwheat Pillow

Brow Farm Organic Buckwheat Pillow

Find out more about Buckwheat pillows in our buyers guide

Cotton

Cotton is 100% natural and is often used to fill pillows and is one of the more affordable options. As result of being natural it means that it's hypoallergenic so is ideal for those that suffer from allergies.

Cotton pillows have a high loft and have strong airflow to keep you cool, wicking away heat from your skin. Cotton pillows may be more affordable but they lose shape and flatten more rapidly. The filling may also clump depending on the positon you sleep in.

Cotton pillows come in a range of different densities, lofts and shapes so regardless of your sleeping positon you can find a cotton pillow to suit you.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Cooling
  • Natural
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Flattens over time
  • Lower Lifespan

Polyester

You’ll struggle to find someone who hasn’t used a polyester pillow at some point throughout their life. Polyester pillows are similar in feel to cotton pillows whilst providing good cooling and loft properties ensuring that you not only stay cool but that your head stays strong supportive position.

Polyester pillows are prone to flattening easily which means that their average lifespan is shorter so will need to be replaced more frequently. Caring for Polyester pillows is easier as they can be machine washed and tumble dried.

They are one of the more affordable types of pillows available on the market. We wouldn’t recommend getting a polyester pillow, however you can get pillows that have a blend of fillings including polyester to allow you to experience all the benefits of it, without the obvious negatives.

Pros

  • Cheaper
  • Machine washable
  • List Element

Cons

  • Loses shape quickly
  • Lower lifespan

Best Pillow By Sleeping Position

Finding the best pillow can be difficult because everybody has different sleeping styles. The position that you sleep in will have a large impact on the pillow you choose depending on whether you sleep on your front, side or back. Some people may not fit into just one sleeping position as you may switch during the night.

Back Sleepers

The main aim for a back sleeper is to keep the neck and spine healthily aligned without raising your head to much as this can cause straining. Loft refers to the height of the pillow, and a medium loft is idea for most back sleepers.

The loft that’s suitable for you will be determined by individually factors such as your weight, size of shoulders and head. For example a heavier person may need slightly higher loft because their weight will sink them further into the pillow.

Our top performers

Simba Luxury Memory Foam Pillow Review

Panda Luxury Memory Foam Bamboo Pillow

Learn more about our top rated pillow for back sleepers

Stomach Sleepers

If you sleep on your front then you need the least amount of loft because the main aim is to keep your head aligned with the rest of your body, so the lower the loft the better. Again, the pillow you choose will be affected the weight of the user, head and shoulder size, so a heavier person may be better suited to a medium lofted pillow.

The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers also has a degree of sink and is soft leading to a comfortable sleep whilst maintain correct spine alignment.

Our top performers

John Lewis Natural White Goose Down Standard Pillow

Soak and Sleep Duck Feather & Down Pillows

Learn more about our top rated pillow for stomach sleepers

Side Sleepers

Side sleepers are often the hardest to find a suitable pillow for because of their loft requirements which is why they’ll often end up folding or scrunching up their pillow to find their ideal loft.

An adjustable loft is ideal because it means you can set your own height preference so your neck and spine remains aligned. Memory foam and latex provide the firmness that you need as well as the loft whereas Down feather pillows provide the adjustable loft to suit your custom needs.

Our top performers

Dunlopillo Latex Pillow

Healthbeds Cooltex Latex Pillow

Learn more about our top rated pillow for side sleepers

Snoring

Snoring isn’t only bad for the you but can also be a massive problem if you’re sharing the same bed with another person. In more severe cases you may need a mouthpiece or head guard, but in most scenarios you might just need to get a more suitable pillow.

Side sleepers don’t usually suffer from snoring and is more common amongst back sleepers. A good memory foam pillow will work to elevate your head which will open up your airways so it’s less likely to be obstructed so your snoring will decrease.

Our top performers

Supportiback Comfort Therapy Bed Wedge Pillow

iCoudy Cervical Contour memory foam Anti snoring pillow

Learn more about our top rated pillow for snorers

Toddlers

A toddler pillow will usually be the first pillow that your child uses nightly, and will also be a sign of the move from sleeping in a cot to a real bed. They are different to an adult pillow because they are smaller in size so it doesn’t cause head or neck issues, whilst also being less irritable on the skin. The key factors to consider are:

Allergies

Babies may be allergic to certain types of substances but haven’t been diagnosed yet, so you’ll need to be extra safe by purchasing a pillow with hypoallergenic material or cover.

Firmness

A soft pillow for a toddler may seem like the best choice but it can actually be an issue because it may not provide enough support so their face sinks into the pillow which can cause suffocation. Ideally you should purchase a medium firm rated toddler pillow.

Filling

The leading toddler pillows use memory foam because this provides excellent support and comfort to the developing toddlers body and provides a more restful sleep.

Our top performers

Panda Kids Luxury Memory Foam Bamboo Toddler

Clevamama ClevaFoam Toddler Pillow

Learn more about our top rated toddler pillows

Pregnancy

During pregnancy, women often use specially designed pregnancy pillows which are enlarged pillows which increase the level of comfort. This is because with the added weight of the baby, a common complaint is that it becomes uncomfortable for the mother to sleep.

Instead of stacking up multiple pillows, a maternity pillow can be used which is usually a U or C shape. This helps to not only alleviate pain, but also prevent pain from developing throughout your pregnancy term. Just like the other pillow types there are some key considerations to be made:

Size

Because pregnancy pillows are large in size, you need to ensure that your chosen pillow will fit in your existing bed and that it fits your body size.

Filling

If you need more support and a hugging effect then memory foam will be suitable, however the most common is polyester as the shape can easily be adjusted to your needs and makes little noise throughout the night

Hypoallergenic

It’s important that the pillow filling or the cover is hypoallergenic not just for the mothers benefit but also the child as they will also suffer from the reaction that the mother has.

Our top performers

PregnancyPillows U shape lavender pillow

Sangool U Shape Pregnancy pillow

Find out more about pregnancy pillows in our buyers guide

Neck Pain

The main cause of neck pain is due to using the wrong mattress or pillow. A pillow may feel comfortable but can still be doing lots of damage whilst you sleep which is why it’s so important to get a pillow that suits your sleeping style:

Back sleepers need a pillow that has a medium loft that provides support and contouring to the spine.

Side Sleepers require more support because less of their body is in contact with the surface.

Front Sleepers need a lower lofted pillow so the head remains aligned with the rest of the body.

Our top performers

Caloics Memory Foam Neck Pillow

Calming Breath Buckwheat Pillow

Find out more about top rated pillows for neck pain in our buyers guide

Allergies

If you suffer from allergic reactions then you don’t need to worry about having a limited choice because the pillow industry has undergone such a transformation, that it’s almost normal for pillows to have hypoallergenic properties which is even more common amonst latex, buckwheat and memory foam.

It’s important to check but either the material, the cover or both will be rated as hypoallergenic.

Cooling

To improve the quality of your sleep, maintaining a comfortable body temperature is incredibly important especially during the summer where this problem can get worse. There are several different versions of a cooling pillow which are:

Memory foam gel pillow – A cooling layer inserted inside the pillow which increases airflow

Cool Gel Pad – A cooling mat that contains a layer of gel that once refrigerated provides cooling

Water pillow – Structured like traditional pillows but has an in-built layer of water

Down pillows – Down naturally promoted airflow in and out of the material keeping you cool

Buying a cooling pillow doesn’t differ from buying any other type of pillow; you still need to consider the overall firmness and size to ensure that it suits your sleeping style.

Closing

So now you’ve made it to the end of the guide you can see that there’s no pillow that is the best for everyone and different pillow types suit different people. What is consistent is that every person needs to take the same factors into account before making a final buying decision:

  • Firmness
  • Cooling
  • Comfort
  • Support

Leave a Reply